Did the characters leave an impression? Do I remember their names?
Did I get lost in the story? Was it interesting? Did it make me think or make me emotional?
Did I enjoy watching it? Would I watch it again?
Is there anything that distracts from the overall enjoyment?
Is the animation distracting in any way, or does it compliment the series?
Is there anything that stands out about the series musically?
Does it have a satisfying ending?
Is the setting clearly defined? If not, is there a clear reason for that?
Did the story mean something to me personally?